An observer of the MSM would conclude a few summers ago that shark attacks on swimmers suddenly skyrocketed. Surely, given the MSM coverage, shark attacks were abnormally high. The media never presented facts about the number of attacks that summer in relation to historical data. There was one spectacular attack at a time that there was little competing news and everyone’s antenna was up about shark news and the next inevitable incident immediately drew headlines.
Reminds me of the time after one spectacular school shooting, that the local news featured a story about a shooting “near a school” when the shooter, the victim and everything about the story had no connection to schools or schoolchildren in any way other than geography. The antenna was up about shooting and school and the wire services were parsed for those words.
Mine tragedies are bad, but should politicians be setting legal safety policies based on media mob psychology? Evey wire story that has the words “coal mine” in it is now considered for national attention. Is mining the most dangerous occupation in the US?
America’s Most Dangerous Jobs
Job Number Of Fatalities Fatality Rate*
Timber Cutters 105 122.1
Fishermen 52 108.3
Pilots 230 100.8
Structural Metal Workers 47 59.5
Extractive Occupations 69 53.9
Roofers 65 30.2
Construction Workers 288 28.3
Truck Drivers 852 27.6
All Occupations 5,915 4.3
All data for calendar year 2000. *Deaths per 100,000 employed. Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Dept. of Labor
America’s Most Dangerous Jobs - Forbs.com
Clearly timber men, pilots and fishermen are about twice as likely to die in an occupational accident than miners. Where is the legislation? Over eight hundred truck drivers die in work related accidents per year compared to fewer than 70 “extractive” workers. If the world were just, I could imagine the TV coverage of the widows and children of 18 wheeler jockeys played up close for a few months. There would be ten times the number of sad people. Facts and actual human tragedy figure little in this game. If you are bit by a shark in the summer of 2006 there are no cameras. If you expire in a coal mine in 2007 the media may have moved on and the ten minutes granted to the family of a co-worker and the hour dedicated to mine safety in January 2006 might be out of your reach forever.
Political decision making is like mob action. It is irrational, subject to chance, inefficient, ineffective. Why anyone would want more spheres of human decision making and resource allocation relegated to politics is beyond my ken.